Faith or mechanics ?

Two days and lots of ‘sannidhi’1 worshipping later, I have a made a few observations/introspections.
I have been observing people praying at the temples. Sometimes I see people with so much religious fervour it makes me feel guilty(?!). Many a time, when I was standing at a place with a nice view of the ‘vigraha’2 I wanted to move away and give the place to the person behind me, who probably deserved it more, or who’d rather have a better use of the darshan. All along, in all the temples, through countless idols, I never could actually evoke any kind of religious reverence or even some kind of respect for what I was seeing. All that did was try and appreciate the sculpting, the architecture, the decorations, etc., but nothing whatsoever, to do with God, worship or faith. And sometimes, I even was really angry when I saw people worshipping. For instance, it’s understandable to suddenly become really all worked up (like lifting their joined hands up over one’s heads and shouting out the Lord’s name) when an ‘abhishekam’3 is being done on the idol (although i fail to understand, how that particular instance is more sanctimonius than when there is just the idol..although it’s supposedly the same God with the same powers!!!). But what really ticked me off was it’s been done so many countless times over that they fail to actually see what’s happening. So they do it mechanically as soon as they see the poojari4 is doing something to the idol. So when the abhishekam is over and the poojari is just washing away the ghee, or milk or whatever that’s been used, again the people start of with the whole hulla!

The next gripe that I have is with people chanting the mantras/shloka. To me, anything that’s been said without knowing/understanding the meaning is useless/pointless. So when I see people trying to keep up with the ‘shastrigal’4 in saying the shlokas, I really get irritated; irritated, because, even knowing whatever little sanskrit i know, i can clearly make out that they are horrendously mispronouncing the words that they have just mindlessly memorised. And even when pronounced correctly, they wouldn’t know what they are praying about. For instance, I have asked many people the meaning of verse in ‘Kanda shasti kavasam’5: ‘Dagu dagu digu digu dangu dingugu, vindhu vindhu mayilon vindhu” (I kid you not, those are the exact words), but i still havn’t got a satisfactory answer. And to me then, a “dagu dagu digu digu dangu dingugu’ has the same significance as a “laalakku dol dappima”6 !

To top it all, there is this commercialization of worship! Chidambaram Natarajar temple is something that i have been wanting to visit for a really long time. And so, it was quite shocking , that when i actually went there, i just couldn’t wait to get out of there. I certainly had my expectations right: I was not so religious, so i didn’t expect an out-of-this-world experience. In fact, the rule about asking men folk to enter the sanctum sanctorum bare-chested actually lent a spirit of something really important about to happen upon entry. But, with the crowd and all those sweaty bodies, I was happy to take a single glance at the idol (which anyway was not visible, partly due to the crowds and mostly due to the really dim lighting inside the altar) and make a quick getaway. But what really left a bad taste was the “kovil pattars’4 marketing the prasadams and selling the blessings. It is quite understandable that the temple is run completely by a family of ‘Gurukkals’4 residing at the temple premises and money is hard to come by! But it should not be done at the expense of taking away the devotees from what they actually came to place for: praying. After a point of time, I was feeling like a deer being stalked by hungry predators. I am actually feeling sad that i really could not appreciate the place, the architecture, the history and the mythology. All that I would think of, when somebody mentions the temple, is not Mr. Natarajar but the face of the sweet talking pattar who tried to get me to pay a whole lot of money to get ‘special’ blessings from God couriered fortnightly to my home!

I am not sure if I am being very critical because I am losing my faith or if it’s this constant exposure to such blind faith/unfounded beliefs/touting that has made me lose any respect for the Almighty, or atleast for the ‘messengers’ of the Almighty.

Footnotes: 

1. place where the idol has been installed/consecrated; an altar

2. idol

3. ceremony of ablutions and symbolic offerings

4. temple priest

5. a prayer to Lord Muruga asking for his blessings

6. the starting words from a Tamil movie song

5 Responses to Faith or mechanics ?

  1. Remember the concept of “residual religion” that you spoke about in your earlier article, I think its more a fit for all of us. Problem with us, is that we are stuck between religion and science. Both cannot co-exists according to me! But we try hard to juggle between the two points. Thats what i see is the problem.

  2. By the way shyam, neat and well written article!

  3. Kanchi maha periyava in one of his discourse —

    Some people say that the places of worship, which belong to other religions, are quiet, but our Hindu temples are full of noise. Of course, this is true. Actually, there are two types of noises in our temples. One is the desirable type of noise such as ringing of bells, the sounding of musical instruments like nadaswaram and the shahnai; the recitation of namavalli archana, recitation of mantras and so on.

    Of course, there is also the undesirable type of noise in the form of people indulging in idle gossip and purposeless talk. It is our duty to see that this idle talk, which results in undesirable noise, is totally eliminated from our temples. In other places of worship, this type of fanfare that we have in our temples, is not there, because they do not recognize idol worship or worship of God in the saguna form and they believe in worship of God in his attributeless and shapeless form only.

    In our temple, a huge temple bell is rung at the time of puja. This is done so that the evil spirits may go away from temple premises, and all abuses or other bad sounds may be stifled from being heard. Same is the case when people chant the divine names while performing abhishekams or upaacharas .

  4. Nalla prasaadam aavadhu saapteengala? :P

  5. Shayam Sundar.
    I guess you are a brahmin by birth. I hope you do not misunderstand my observation. Culture has an influence on spiritual disposition and quest. Like Brahmins mostly brought up in an environment of “worship by the vedas” whereas non-brahmins like the extreme “Sudala Madasamy” and “Mariamma worshipper” who prepare “Aadi Maasam Koozh”.

    Before I continue my comment let me just tell you about “dagu dagu..”
    (and before that I am an Athiest-Agnostic in between)

    the “dagu dagu..” is the sound of the salangai bells from the subject of the song (Murugan)…see the start of the song..
    பாதமிரண்டில் பன்மணிச் சதங்கை
    கீதம் பாடக் கிண்கிணி ஆட

    as far as “vindhu” is concerned it may not be the “Semen”..but (this my interpretation) it might be the “peacock” vehicle.
    VIN (Sky) + UNDHU (force) = VINDHU like “PERUNDHU” for Bus

    So the poet is just singing “Go peacock Go and Go Vel Go..”

    I am sure there are lot of dumbos now.
    But I have a feeling that the persons who wrote those had a very above average intelligence and intellectual those days. Just like the various sculptors, architects, kings, ministers, etc etc..

    I also believe in those days good people and talented people may have been worshipped as god. Why not? they have no police, no laws, no electricty, no guns…no doctors, no clinics…so who saved them?..some great men and great leaders at that time..some king gave “wealth” to some one…some “warrior” protected the people from bad guys (asuras)..some nerdy in the forest gave life saving medicines. (sure our puranasa identify “Munivargal”…but there might have been some super humans who they considered god..(probably that super man knew how to count without using fingers, or knew strategy, or some talent)

    The people felt so indebted to them, they owed thier life to them..they started singing “praises”…their praises sort of exaggerated the “gods”..like a 3 hour movie…

    This intellects again were much respected by the down stream people…
    so they believe in the intellects “poem” and hence believe in the “god”…

    If you see..there are so many “local gods”…(this is where I doubt the “vedic conspiracy”) now the kings need “unification”..to create adhesion and loyalty to the king..people from different cultures need to be united by the kings so that they can rule easily..

    so the king says…”hey you there..what are you worshipping..?? I am worshipping “Thandu Muthu MAriamma…my lord.”"…hey that is another avatar of “Parvathi”…she is amman…”

    so the networking and linking starts..every local god is the son of or wife of or father of finally Shiva or Vishnu (poor brahma..)

    So from Kashmir to Kanyakumari..finally Hinduism is formed…

    Religion was used by the kings to control vast empires.
    with less force and resources. Myths and gods were created.
    To reinforce this Kings built “Architectural Marvels..” called temples.
    ..people now looked with “awe..” (imagine those dumb commoners of those days..)

    Kings had “court poets” who did nothing but create “fiction..” and “exaggerations..”

    This is religion to me.

    As far as god is concerned..
    I strongly believe that “some body wants something to happen..” because I see lots of pattern in the “motives of life” I am seeing patterns in how the life animates itself.

    “..Some body (or something )wants something to happen..”
    who is that? and what does it want?
    (dot say god.)

    Siva
    Calgary
    Feb-2012

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s